Skip to contentSkip to content
Masterbuilt 40" Digital Electric Smoker tested by SmokyHQ

Electric GrillsHands-on review

Masterbuilt 40 Inch Electric Smoker Review 2026: Steady Heat

Set the temperature and walk away: it held 225°F within 8 to 10°F on every cook, even in cold wind, with room for two pork shoulders and two racks of ribs. Easiest smoking for beginners, lighter bark than charcoal.

By Marcus ReillyLast updated:13 min read

Good fit

Ranked #4 · 5 electric grills tested

Best for: Beginners and flame-restricted patios that want hands-off smoking

  • Temperature consistency9.6
  • Ease of use9.6
  • Capacity9.0
  • Build and warranty7.4
  • Value for money8.4
  • Smoke flavor6.4

Hands-on · 3 weeksHow we score

4.2

Our verdictGood fit

Plug in, set a temperature and walk away: the easiest big smoker for beginners and flame-restricted patios.

Electric Grill · Electric · hands-on tested

Brand
Masterbuilt
Cooking area
970 sq in across 4 racks
Fuel
Electric
Tested for
3 weeks

What we liked

  • Held a 225°F setpoint within 8–10°F on every test cook, even in cold and wind
  • Four chrome racks fit two pork shoulders and two racks of ribs at once
  • Side wood chip loader lets you add chips without opening the door

What could be better

  • Smoke flavor and bark are milder than charcoal or pellets
  • Tops out at 275°F, so it cannot sear or crisp poultry skin well
  • Needs a GFCI-protected 120V outlet within reach

Buy it if

Beginners and flame-restricted patios that want hands-off smoking

Skip it if

Bark chasers, or anyone without an outdoor outlet

The Masterbuilt 40 inch electric smoker is the smoker to buy if you want to set a temperature, walk away and still feed a crowd. In our Masterbuilt 40 inch electric smoker review it scored 4.2 out of 5: it held a 225°F setpoint within 8–10°F on every cook, even in cold wind, and its four racks fit two pork shoulders and two racks of ribs at once. Skip it if bark is what you chase; chips on an electric element give lighter smoke and softer bark than charcoal or pellets.

Black Masterbuilt cabinet smoker with a glass door and four empty racks on raised legs on a patioThe window-and-legs version: four chrome racks behind the glass, raised to a comfortable working height.

Our electric grill and smoker reviews hub compares it with every other plug-in cooker we have tested.

How We Tested

Three weeks, eight sessions with wood chips, probes at several rack heights.

Marcus Reilly smoked on the Masterbuilt for three weeks on a concrete patio, across eight sessions with wood chips.

  • Food: two overnight pork shoulders, a full-load test with two shoulders and two racks of ribs, and chicken thighs at 250°F.
  • Weather: a 36°F morning start and 15 mph gusts, the conditions that make cheap smokers swing.
  • Measurements: external probes at several rack heights, to map heat from top to bottom.
  • Specs: checked against Masterbuilt's product page.

Each smoker gets a score out of 10 in six categories: temperature consistency, ease of use, capacity, build and warranty, value for money and smoke flavor. They roll up into the overall score out of 5 in the Final Score.

Three weeks can't show long-term rust, controller and element life, or how parts hold up after several seasons. We list the parts that wear first under durability and update this review if problems show up.

Test log · category ranking

How it ranks against rivals

#4 of 5

electric grills rank

4.2/5

avg 4.3 in category

9.6/10

best test score

Where it ranks

Overall score out of 5

  1. 1Ninja Woodfire ProConnect Premium XL (OG951)Ninja Woodfire ProConnect Premium XL (OG951)Electric4.4
  2. 2Ninja Sizzle Indoor Grill & Griddle (GR101)Ninja Sizzle Indoor Grill & Griddle (GR101)Electric4.3
  3. 3Weber Lumin Compact Electric GrillWeber Lumin Compact Electric GrillElectric4.3
  4. 4Masterbuilt 40" Digital Electric SmokerMasterbuilt 40" Digital Electric SmokerThis review4.2
  5. 5Ninja Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 Indoor Grill (FG551)Ninja Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 Indoor Grill (FG551)Electric4.2

Key Specs

SpecMasterbuilt 40" Digital ElectricWhat it means for you
Cooking area970 sq in, 4 chrome racksAbout double an 18-inch bullet smoker's rack space
Temperature range100–275°FSmoking and jerky; no searing
HeatingElectric element, 1,200 W on Masterbuilt's 40" digital lineNeeds a solid 120V outlet
Smoke sourcePatented side wood chip loaderSized for chips, not chunks
BodyFully insulated cabinetHolds heat in cold and wind
DimensionsAbout 26 x 20 x 41 in (W x D x H)Small footprint for the capacity
ModelMB20072918 (base)Window-and-legs version also sold
AssemblyAbout 40 minutes solo in our testA one-person job
Warranty1 yearShort; use a cover
Check Current PricePrices change often, so check the retailer for today’s price.

Will It Hold Temperature While You Sleep?

Yes: it held 225°F within 8–10°F on every cook, including the 36°F start and 15 mph gusts.

Steady heat is this smoker's biggest strength, and it's the reason to buy one. The digital controller cycles the element to hold your setpoint, and the insulated cabinet keeps wind and cold from pulling the temperature around.

Heat was also even from top rack to bottom, so food never needed rotating. That means you can sleep through the stall instead of tending a fire.

Man checking the digital controller on top of a Masterbuilt cabinet smoker with a probe receiver beside itProbes at several rack heights showed even heat top to bottom, so nothing needed rotating.

What this means for you: if you've ever lost a night to a charcoal fire that wandered, this is the fix. Set the temperature and time on the panel, put a probe in the meat, and check the window instead of opening the door.

The one limit is the top end. It maxes out at 275°F, so it can't sear, and poultry skin stays soft. For crisp skin, finish chicken on a hot grill.

Does an Electric Smoker Give Real Smoke Flavor and Bark?

You get a smoke ring and clear wood flavor, but lighter bark than charcoal.

This is the trade for convenience, and it's why smoke flavor is its lowest score. Chips smolder on the hot element rather than burn, so there's less combustion gas in the cabinet, and that gas is part of what builds a deep, dark crust.

How to get more smoke and bark from it

Technique closes part of the gap:

  • Pick strong, dry wood: hickory or mesquite chips, never soaked. Wet chips have to steam off water before they smoke. Our wood chips guide has pairings.
  • Add chips steadily: about a cup at a time, every 45–60 minutes early in the cook, through the side loader so the door stays shut.
  • Dry the surface: pat meat dry and rub it the night before. A dry, tacky surface takes smoke and forms bark better.
  • Front-load the smoke: meat absorbs most of its smoke in the first few hours, so keep chips coming then and let the controller finish on heat alone.
  • Skip the wrap until late: leave the meat unwrapped through the stall so the bark can set.
  • Use the air damper: keep the top damper partly open so smoke keeps moving and doesn't turn stale and bitter.
  • Finish on a grill: a few minutes over direct heat crisps chicken skin or firms a crust.

None of this turns it into a charcoal smoker. It does make the difference between pale, steamed-tasting meat and proper barbecue. If smoke depth is your priority, our pellet grill vs traditional smoker guide explains what each fuel delivers.

Can you cold smoke cheese?

Not on its own setting. The lowest setting is 100°F, warmer than the roughly 90°F at which cheese starts to soften and sweat. A separate cold-smoke attachment, or a pellet tube with the element off on a cool day, is the usual workaround.

How Much Can the Masterbuilt 40" Smoke at Once?

Two pork shoulders and two racks of ribs, with room for smoke to move.

Our full-load test filled all four racks with space between cuts. That's enough for a big gathering, and it's where the 40" earns its price over smaller cabinets.

Rack of ribs and a pork shoulder with dark bark on chrome racks inside an open cabinet smokerRibs and a pork shoulder share the cabinet in our full-load test, with racks to spare.

Masterbuilt rates it for up to 16 chickens, 4 turkeys, 8 pork butts or 8 racks of ribs. That assumes tightly packed racks; leave gaps if you want even smoke.

How to load a mixed cook

  • Poultry on the bottom: raw chicken drippings shouldn't fall onto pork or beef. The bottom rack sits right above the water bowl, which catches them.
  • Fatty cuts up top: pork shoulder does fine on the upper racks.
  • Keep flavors apart: leave an empty rack between cuts, or slide a foil pan underneath.
  • Biggest cuts low: put the largest cuts on the lower racks and smaller cuts above.

Start with our pork shoulder guide or ribs guide, and pull meat by internal temperature with a probe; our meat temperature chart lists the targets.

What Does It Take to Set Up, Run and Maintain?

About 40 minutes to build, an outdoor GFCI outlet, and a few minutes of cleanup per cook.

Assembly and first run

Assembly took about 40 minutes solo. Run Masterbuilt's seasoning burn before the first cook to burn off manufacturing oils.

Man kneeling on a drop cloth in a garage assembling a black electric cabinet smoker with an open glass doorBuilding it in the garage is fine; move it out to an open patio before the seasoning burn.

Where you can (and can't) use it

Placement rules are stricter than many buyers expect for an electric smoker:

  • Outdoors only, at least 10 feet from any structure.
  • No covered areas: Masterbuilt rules out garages, covered porches and other covered spaces.
  • No combustible surfaces: that includes a wood deck without protection.

In practice, that means an open patio or a concrete pad with a GFCI outdoor outlet nearby. Most apartment balconies can't meet those rules, so check your lease and fire code before buying.

Power: why the outlet matters

Plug in directly: long, light-duty extension cords can stop it reaching temperature. If the nearest outlet is far away, have an electrician add one.

The math explains why. The element draws about 10 amps at 120V, most of a standard 15-amp household circuit. If a freezer, pool pump or space heater shares that circuit, a breaker can trip mid-cook and the smoker stops heating. Use a circuit with little else running, especially overnight.

How a typical cook goes

  1. Fill the water bowl. It adds moisture and catches drippings. Top it up when you add chips on long cooks; hot water helps the cabinet recover faster on cold days. Leave it dry for jerky.
  2. Set temperature and time. The digital panel takes both, so you aren't watching a dial all day.
  3. Preheat with the first chips. Load chips once the element is warm, so they're smoking as the meat goes on.
  4. Load meat cold, biggest cuts low, with gaps for smoke to move.
  5. Leave the door shut. Every opening dumps heat the element has to rebuild.
  6. Pull by probe, not clock. The digital timer only counts down.

Man smiling at a Masterbuilt electric smoker on a sunset patio set for dinnerWith the controller holding temperature, the cook gets to sit down with the guests.

What to cook first

  • Pork shoulder: it tolerates a wide range of finishing temperatures, and the controller handles the long stall.
  • Chicken thighs: a short, easy cook that shows the smoke ring and flavor; crisp the skin on a hot grill after. Our smoked chicken guide covers it.
  • Jerky: the low end of the range suits drying, and four racks hold a big batch.

Plan timing generously. A common rule of thumb for pork shoulder at 225°F is about 1.5–2 hours per pound, so an 8 lb shoulder can take 12–16 hours once the stall is included.

Save brisket for later. It's possible here, but its bark depends on strong smoke and airflow, which is where an electric smoker is weakest.

Cold and wet weather

The insulated cabinet handles cold well, but winter cooks need longer preheats, so start earlier than in summer. A spot shielded from the prevailing wind helps the element cycle less. Fit a weatherproof in-use cover on the outlet so rain or snow can't trip it.

Rain is a bigger risk than cold, because the controller is the most vulnerable part. Skip cooks in heavy rain; moving it under a roof isn't an option given the placement rules.

Cleanup

After each cook, empty the drip pan, water bowl, rear grease tray and chip tray, wipe the interior and soak the racks.

Masterbuilt's cleaning tip: mix equal parts hot water and apple cider vinegar in a spray bottle, spray the interior and wipe with a soft sponge. It cuts grease without harsh chemicals. Leave a light coat of smoke on the walls; scrubbing back to bare metal isn't needed. Never hose down the cabinet.

Running costs

Electric smoking is cheap to run. At the 1,200 W element rating, even an hour flat out uses only 1.2 kWh, and once the cabinet is up to temperature the controller cycles the element, so real use is lower. To estimate your cost, multiply 1.2 by your cooking hours and your local rate per kWh; that's the ceiling.

Other consumables are wood chips and, if you use them, foil or drip pan liners. A standard bag of chips covers several cooks, since you only need chips during the smoking phase.

Versions, accessories and storage

Masterbuilt sells this smoker in a few forms, per its product page:

VersionDifference
30-inch Digital ElectricSmaller cabinet for small households
40-inch Digital Electric (MB20072918)The base model we reviewed
40-inch with Window and LegsAdds legs for a better working height

Legs save bending to reach the lower racks and the chip loader, which you'll notice on long cooks. Some 40" listings include a built-in meat probe and others don't, so check before you buy.

  • A fitted cover: with only a 1-year warranty, keeping the controller dry is the best protection you can buy.
  • A wireless meat probe, if your version has no built-in probe.
  • Replacement parts: Masterbuilt's parts catalog lists parts for this model, so a failed element or controller is replaceable.

For winter storage, clean it thoroughly, let it dry with the door cracked open and store it covered in a dry place. Check that the lockable latch still pulls the door tight before the next season.

Who Should Buy the Masterbuilt 40" (and Who Shouldn't)

A set-and-forget smoker for beginners and flame-restricted patios.

Buy it if you

  • Are new to smoking and want the easiest start

  • Live with open-flame restrictions

  • Want lots of rack space for little money

  • Value steady temperatures over bold smoke

Look elsewhere if you

  • Want the deepest smoke flavor and bark

  • Don't have an outlet where you'll smoke

  • Want to sear on the same unit

  • Want app control (this base model has none)

Match two or more points on either side and you have your answer.

Masterbuilt 40" vs. Alternatives

Most shoppers weigh it against a charcoal bullet, a propane cabinet or a pellet grill.

Masterbuilt 30 vs 40

For two to four people, the 30-inch is often enough. Choose the 40" if you cook whole shoulders or several racks of ribs at once, since its extra height is what fits a full load.

The Masterbuilt wins where the others can't go: patios without gas or charcoal allowed, and cooks who want to set it before bed and sleep. Our best smokers for beginners guide compares these in more depth.

When to pick an alternative instead

Common Problems and Fixes

Most complaints are about smoke, power or moisture, and each has a simple fix.

ProblemLikely causeFix
Weak smoke flavorSoaked or mild chips, or too few refillsDry hickory or mesquite, a cup every 45–60 minutes early on
Little or no smokeAsh in the chip trayEmpty and scrape the tray before each cook
Won't reach temperatureLong extension cord or shared circuitPlug in directly on a circuit with little else running
Breaker trips mid-cookAnother appliance on the same circuitMove to a less-loaded circuit
Bitter, stale smokeDamper closedKeep the top damper partly open
Smoke leaking at the doorWorn sealCheck and replace the door gasket
Controller errorsMoistureKeep it covered and out of rain

Is the Masterbuilt 40 Inch Electric Smoker Worth the Money?

Yes, if steady, hands-off smoking matters more to you than bold flavor.

Value verdict

The value is in the capacity and the controller. A household that feeds a full table gets the most from it; one that smokes for two most weekends gets less, and the 30-inch may do.

  • Temperatures held within 8–10°F

    Smoke depth and bark

  • 970 sq in across four racks

    Searing (275°F max)

  • Almost no learning curve

    A long warranty (1 year)

  • No tank, charcoal or fire to manage

    Use anywhere without an outlet

If flavor comes first, the Weber Smokey Mountain costs only a little more.

Final Score

SmokyHQ score

Good fit

Best at Temperature consistency
Weakest at Smoke flavor

  • Temperature consistency9.6/10
  • Ease of use9.6/10
  • Capacity9.0/10
  • Build and warranty7.4/10
  • Value for money8.4/10
  • Smoke flavor6.4/10

Scores settled? See today’s price on the Masterbuilt 40" Digital Electric Smoker.

If you want steady, hands-off smoking and can live with milder flavor, the Masterbuilt 40" is an easy recommendation.

Next steps: compare it with charcoal in our Weber Smokey Mountain 18" review, or see all our best smokers for beginners.

Ranked in our buying guides

Durability

What to watch over time

Controller and heating element
The likely failure points; keep the smoker covered and dry.
Door seal
Watch for smoke leaks around the door as the seal ages.
Wood chip tray
Ash and creosote build up; clean it before each cook for steady smoke.

Based on the materials, design and warranty we documented during testing. Long-term ownership results are added to reviews as our testers log them.

Frequently Asked Questions

01

Is the Masterbuilt 40-inch electric smoker worth it?

Yes, for hands-off smoking. It held 225°F within 8–10°F on every cook and fits two shoulders and two racks of ribs at once. If bark matters most, a charcoal smoker is the better buy.

02

Is the Masterbuilt 40-inch electric smoker good for beginners?

Yes. The controller does the fire management for you, so a first-timer can focus on rubs, timing and internal temperatures.

03

Do electric smokers taste as good as charcoal?

Not quite, because chips smolder rather than burn. Dry, strong chips added early and an unwrapped stall narrow the gap.

04

How hot does the Masterbuilt 40" get?

It tops out at 275°F, with a low of 100°F. That covers smoking and jerky, but not searing or crisp poultry skin.

05

Does the Masterbuilt 40" come with a meat probe?

Some versions do and others don't, so check the listing before you buy.

06

Can you use a Masterbuilt electric smoker on a balcony?

Usually not. Masterbuilt requires outdoor use at least 10 feet from any structure and nothing overhead, which most balconies can't meet.

07

Can I add wood chunks instead of chips?

No. The side loader is sized for chips, and chunks won't feed through it.

08

How long does the Masterbuilt 40" take to assemble?

About 40 minutes solo in our test. Run the seasoning burn before the first cook.

Written by

Marcus Reilly

Head Pitmaster & Lead Tester

Marcus Reilly is a KCBS Certified Judge with 15 years of competition barbecue. He leads SmokyHQ’s smoker, pellet, charcoal and kamado testing, so if you’re choosing a cooker for brisket, ribs or overnight smokes, his reviews tell you which ones hold temperature and which ones fall short.

  • Smokers
  • Pellet Grills
  • Charcoal & Kamado
  • Low-and-Slow BBQ
  • Temperature Control

Every grill is bought with our own money and scored on the same tests. How we test