How much cooking area do you need?
Look at the primary grate, not the total. Totals include the warming rack, which holds food off the heat: the Char-Broil's 737.3 sq in total includes a 202.3 sq in rack, while the Broil King puts 500 of its 695 sq in on the main grate.
Where a maker gives a capacity figure, use it. Monument gives one for the Mesa and the Denali.
Do BTUs and burner count matter?
BTU measures how much gas a grill can burn per hour, not how well it sears. Compare the sear design instead: Weber boosts part of the main burners (Boost on the Spirit, Boost Mode on the Genesis), Monument adds a Broil Zone on the Mesa and a dedicated infrared sear burner on the Denali, and Char-Broil's Amplifire system runs infrared across the grill.
More burners give you more zones you can set separately, which is what lets you cook hot on one side and gently on the other. For steak-first grills, see our best grills for steaks.
Cast iron or stainless grates?
Five of these grills use cast iron: porcelain-enameled on the Genesis, Spirit and Mesa, porcelain-coated on the Char-Broil and plain cast iron on the Denali. The Broil King uses stainless grids. Each needs different care; our guide on how to clean grill grates covers both.
Propane or natural gas?
Propane works anywhere a tank can go. Natural gas needs a gas line to the patio and a grill made or converted for it, and the routes differ by model:
- Sold as a natural gas model: the Broil King Regal S 420 Pro we reviewed.
- Converts with the maker's kit: the Char-Broil Pro Series, with kit 8216842R04.
- Propane only: the Monument Mesa 415BZ and Denali 605Pro.
Convert a grill only with the maker's own kit for that model, following its instructions.
How much does the warranty matter?
More than the headline suggests, because terms are set by part. The Broil King covers the cookbox for life; the Char-Broil covers its burners for 10 years but the grates and firebox for 3; the Royal Gourmet covers everything for 1 year. Read the part-by-part terms before you choose.